Many blockchain protocols generate substantial value for their users but fail to transfer any of that value back to their token holders. Uniswap, for instance, facilitates significant trading volume and generates considerable fees, yet none of that revenue is shared with UNI token holders. This highlights a critical challenge in the crypto space: designing tokens that not only create value but also effectively capture it.
For a token to achieve long-term success, it must evolve beyond pure speculation and become a productive asset. This requires a deliberate design that links the protocol's value generation to tangible benefits for token holders. Understanding both value creation and value capture mechanisms is essential for accurately assessing a token's intrinsic worth and potential valuation.
Understanding Value Creation and Value Capture
Value creation refers to the process of generating new value or enhancing existing value through innovation, improved efficiency, or other means. In practical terms, this can manifest as increased productivity, reduced operational costs, or greater accessibility for users.
Value capture involves retaining a portion of the value that a product, service, or system generates. Using a simple analogy: if a lemonade stand spends $50 on ingredients and sells $100 worth of lemonade, it creates $100 in value but captures only $50 as profit.
These two concepts are deeply interconnected. Innovation theorist Peter Thiel famously stated that value creation is about inventing something new, while value capture is about monetizing that innovation. For any business—or crypto protocol—to succeed, both elements must work in harmony.
How Crypto Protocols Create and Capture Value
Blockchain protocols create value in numerous measurable ways, including generated fees, total value locked (TVL), active user counts, and user engagement time. Several protocol archetypes exemplify strong value creation:
- Decentralized Exchanges (DEXs) like Uniswap offer low fees, deep liquidity, and accessibility for any tokenized asset.
- Staking Platforms such as Lido enable users to earn yields without managing complex staking infrastructure.
- Crypto Gaming projects provide utility and entertainment to players.
- Smart Contract Platforms allow for the execution of decentralized applications.
However, creating value does not automatically mean capturing it. Many protocols struggle to design mechanisms that redirect a portion of their generated value back to the token holders.
Tokens That Successfully Capture Value
Smart Contract Platform Tokens (e.g., ETH)
Layer-1 smart contract platform tokens like Ethereum's ETH have robust value capture mechanisms. ETH serves as the native currency for transaction fees, meaning users must acquire it to interact with the network. This creates direct demand linked to platform usage.
Ethereum captures value through transaction fees that exceed operational expenses, leading to a deflationary effect that reduces supply and supports the token's price. This mechanism is strengthened by network effects: as more developers build applications on Ethereum, demand for ETH increases, making the network more valuable and attracting further development.
Crypto Gaming Tokens
When designed responsibly—avoiding Ponzi-like structures—crypto gaming tokens can effectively capture value. If a game is genuinely enjoyable and players are willing to spend money within it, the in-game token gains intrinsic value. These tokens create value through entertainment and capture value via monetization mechanisms within the game ecosystem.
It's worth noting that many early crypto games relied heavily on speculation rather than genuine gameplay, leading to unsustainable economies. For long-term success, the game itself must be engaging enough to create real, lasting value.
Tokens That Fail to Capture Value
The Case of Uniswap and Governance Tokens
To assess the intrinsic value of DeFi tokens like Uniswap's UNI, one must examine the token's relationship to the underlying protocol. While Uniswap generates significant value through fees and high TVL, these benefits are not shared with UNI holders. Currently, token demand is driven mainly by governance rights and speculation about future utility.
Governance alone offers limited value capture. It allows token holders to vote on protocol decisions, but this represents a thin slice of the overall value generated. For UNI to capture more value, the protocol could implement a fee-sharing mechanism, though such a move may not align with current strategic goals.
Note: Uniswap is used here as a well-known example and not due to any particular bias.
Common Methods for Token Value Capture
Several mechanisms can enable tokens to capture value:
- Revenue Sharing: Token holders receive a percentage of the protocol's revenue, such as transaction fees or staking rewards.
Example: Lido distributes staking rewards to $LDO holders. - Governance: Tokens confer voting rights on protocol upgrades and changes.
Example: Curve's $CRV grants governance rights that are highly valued due to the protocol's role in stablecoin liquidity. - Token Utility: Tokens are used as a medium of exchange within the platform for fees, services, or purchases.
Example: Braintrust's $BTRST tokens provide access to software discounts and career resources. - Scarcity: Limited token supply can drive value appreciation as demand increases.
Example: Ethereum's ETH has a capped supply and deflationary mechanisms. - Intrinsic Value: Tokens provide access to exclusive content, services, or community benefits.
Example: BanklessDAO's $BANK tokens offer membership perks and governance rights.
👉 Explore advanced token design strategies
The Path to Future Token Success
As the cryptocurrency industry matures, investors and developers are increasingly focusing on tokens that offer clear value capture mechanisms. Evaluating both how a token creates value and how it captures that value is crucial for assessing its long-term potential.
Successful token design requires balancing innovation with sustainable economics. Tokens must provide real utility to holders, whether through revenue sharing, governance, or functional use within the ecosystem. The next generation of successful tokens will be those that move beyond speculation and embed value capture directly into their design.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between value creation and value capture?
Value creation is about generating new value through innovation or efficiency, while value capture refers to the ability to retain some of that value as profit or tokenholder benefit. Both are necessary for a sustainable business or protocol.
Why don't all tokens capture value effectively?
Many protocols prioritize user growth and ecosystem expansion over tokenholder benefits. Additionally, some value capture mechanisms, like fee sharing, may involve regulatory or strategic complexities that protocols wish to avoid.
Can governance alone provide sufficient value capture?
While governance rights offer some value, they are often insufficient on their own. Governance tokens derive most of their value from the expectation of future utility or revenue sharing, not just voting rights.
How does token scarcity drive value?
A limited token supply can create upward price pressure as demand increases. This is often combined with deflationary mechanisms like token burning to enhance scarcity effects.
What role does utility play in value capture?
Tokens with practical utility—such as those used for payments, access, or services—have inherent demand beyond speculation. This utility supports long-term value retention and growth.
Are crypto gaming tokens a good investment?
They can be, if the game is genuinely engaging and the token economy is well-designed. Avoid games that rely purely on speculative mechanics without sustainable gameplay or revenue models.