On April 15, 2024, the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) of Hong Kong approved three fund management companies to launch spot exchange-traded funds (ETFs) for Bitcoin and Ethereum. The approved issuers are China Asset Management (Hong Kong), Bosera Asset Management (International), and Harvest Global Investments. These products are expected to be officially listed by the end of April.
This move is set to position Hong Kong as a significant hub for cryptocurrency investment, potentially making it the world's second-largest market for Bitcoin spot ETFs. It also reflects Hong Kong’s broader strategy to enhance its competitiveness and openness within the Web3 ecosystem.
Why Hong Kong Approved Spot Crypto ETFs Now
Hong Kong has been actively promoting the development of the cryptocurrency industry since 2022. In late 2022, the city introduced Bitcoin futures ETFs. The recent approval of spot ETFs is influenced by two key factors:
- Regulatory developments in major markets, including the launch of a spot Bitcoin ETF in the United Kingdom in August 2023 and the approval of 11 Bitcoin spot ETFs in the United States in early 2024.
- Hong Kong’s ambition to establish a leading position in the crypto and Web3 space, attracting global investors and businesses.
How Hong Kong’s Regulatory Approach Differs
Hong Kong’s regulatory framework for crypto ETFs shows notable differences compared to the U.S. model:
- The SFC approved both Bitcoin and Ethereum spot ETFs, while U.S. regulators have so far only greenlighted Bitcoin ETFs.
- Hong Kong allows "in-kind" creation and redemption, meaning investors can use Bitcoin directly to purchase ETF shares. This offers greater flexibility, faster processing, and improved liquidity.
- In contrast, U.S. Bitcoin ETFs operate under a "cash-only" model, where investors use cash to buy shares, and authorized participants handle the Bitcoin transactions. This reflects a more cautious stance from American regulators.
Hong Kong’s virtual asset regulatory regime involves three primary licenses:
- Type 1 License: Permits licensed firms to trade virtual asset financial products on behalf of clients.
- Type 7 License: Allows the provision of automated trading services for virtual assets.
- Type 9 License: Authorizes the management of investment portfolios focused on virtual assets and offers related advisory services.
Notably, platforms like HashKey and OKX have already obtained Type 1 and Type 7 licenses. With the new ETF approvals, asset managers like China Asset Management, Bosera, and Harvest can expand their existing Type 9 licensed services to include virtual asset management.
👉 Explore advanced trading strategies
Projected Capital Inflows for Hong Kong Bitcoin ETFs
Market opinions vary widely regarding how much capital Hong Kong’s new Bitcoin spot ETFs might attract. Estimates range from $500 million to several billion dollars.
- Optimistic View: Points to the U.S. market, where Bitcoin spot ETFs attracted approximately $10 billion in net inflows within two months of launch, demonstrating strong institutional and retail demand.
- Conservative Estimate: Suggests inflows may be limited to around $500 million, considering the relative size of Hong Kong’s ETF market (approximately $52 billion) compared to the U.S. (over $8 trillion) or other Asian markets like Japan ($533.8 billion) and South Korea ($91.3 billion).
A critical factor for Hong Kong’s success will be its ability to attract capital from mainland China through southbound investment channels and from investors across Asia.
Key Market Participants and Potential Benefits
The introduction of spot crypto ETFs in Hong Kong is expected to benefit several key players:
- ETF Issuers: Stand to gain significant management fee revenue. In the U.S., Bitcoin ETFs held over $56.22 billion in assets as of mid-April, accounting for 4.3% of Bitcoin’s total market capitalization, with cumulative net inflows exceeding $12.53 billion.
- Custodians: Companies like OSL and HashKey, which provide custodial services, may see increased revenue from custody fees and transaction charges. While these firms already held relevant licenses, high operational costs and limited tradable assets previously constrained growth.
- Potential Shifts: Bitcoin futures ETFs may experience outflows as investors likely prefer spot ETFs for their superior liquidity and more accurate price tracking.
Understanding the Risks
Investing in virtual asset ETFs involves certain risks that investors should consider:
- Price Volatility: Cryptocurrency prices can be highly volatile, leading to significant gains or losses.
- Technology and Security Risks: Underlying blockchain technology and digital wallets may be vulnerable to security breaches, hacking, or operational failures.
- Regulatory Changes: The regulatory environment for digital assets is still evolving globally and in Hong Kong, which could impact ETF operations and valuations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a spot Bitcoin ETF?
A spot Bitcoin ETF is an exchange-traded fund that holds actual Bitcoin. Its share price is designed to track the live market price of Bitcoin, allowing investors to gain exposure to Bitcoin without directly buying, storing, or managing the cryptocurrency themselves.
How does Hong Kong's 'in-kind' model work?
The "in-kind" creation model allows authorized participants (APs) to use actual Bitcoin to create new shares of the ETF. This is different from the "cash" model used in the U.S., where APs use cash, and the fund's manager is responsible for converting that cash into Bitcoin.
Can mainland Chinese investors buy these ETFs?
Currently, the primary mechanism for mainland investors to access Hong Kong-listed securities is through programs like Stock Connect. Whether these new crypto ETFs will be included in such programs is a key factor that will influence their ability to attract significant capital from mainland China.
Why is Ethereum inclusion significant?
Hong Kong's approval of both Bitcoin and Ethereum spot ETFs signals a broader acceptance of major cryptocurrencies beyond just Bitcoin. This could pave the way for more diverse crypto investment products in the future.
What are the main benefits of investing through an ETF?
ETFs offer a familiar, regulated, and convenient way for traditional investors to access cryptocurrencies. Benefits include ease of trading on traditional exchanges, enhanced security through professional custody, and potential tax advantages in some jurisdictions.
How does this affect Hong Kong's Web3 ambitions?
The approval of these ETFs is a strong signal of Hong Kong's commitment to becoming a leading global hub for Web3 and virtual asset innovation. It is likely to attract more businesses, talent, and investment to its digital asset ecosystem.